S8 — Radial Collapse (Planck)
0.832
S8 — Rotational Collapse (BFUT)
0.7805
KiDS-1000 Observed Deficit
~8.3%
S8 parameter vs mass scale. Blue = radial collapse (Lambda-CDM/Planck). Green = rotational collapse (BFUT). Each point = mean over N structures. Seed 1401.
z=0.4 deficit (KiDS eff.)
8.3%
z=2 deficit (CMB lensing)
4.1%
Pattern
Grows toward low z
S8 deficit (%) vs redshift z. Low-z lensing surveys see large deficit; CMB lensing at high-z agrees with Planck. This redshift pattern distinguishes BFUT from all other explanations. Seed 1405.